What Is Project Portfolio Management (PPM)?
By Michael Greer
February 10, 2010
Project Portfolio Management (PPM) is a management process designed to help an organization acquire and view information about all of its projects, then sort and prioritize each project according to certain criteria, such as strategic value, impact on resources, cost, and so on. The objectives of PPM are similar to the objectives of managing a financial portfolio: 1) To become conscious of all the individual listings in the portfolio 2) To develop a “big picture” view and a deeper understanding of the the collection as a whole. 3) To allow sensible sorting, adding, and removing of items from the collection based on their costs, benefits, and alignment with long-term strategies or goals. 4) To allow the portfolio owner to get the “best bang for the buck” from resources invested.
Typically, PPM begins with the organization developing an inventory (comprehensive list) of all its projects and enough descriptive information about each to allow them to be analyzed and compared. Such descriptive info can include project name, estimated duration, estimated cost, business objective, how the project supports the organization’s overall strategies, and so on. These are sometimes compiled in an electronic database so they may be analyzed and compared more easily.
After the project inventory is created, the PPM process requires department heads or other unit leaders to examine each project and prioritize itaccording to established criteria.** The overall list of projects is then considered in order to develop a well-balanced list of supported projects. Some projects will be given high priority and extensive support, some will be given moderate priority, and still others will be placed on hold or dropped entirely from the list.
Finally, the project portfolio is reevaluated by the portfolio management team on a regular basis (monthly, quarterly, etc.) to determine which projects are meeting their goals, which may need more support, or which may need to be down-sized or dropped entirely. Since the circumstances of each project and the business environment can change rapidly, PPM is most effective when the portfolio is frequently revisited and actively managed by the team.
In order for the above PPM activities to take place, the organization must first decide who will participate as active managers of the PPM process. Typically, the PPM management team is made up of department heads from sub-organizations which generate requests for projects, provide project resources (especially team members), provide project funding, use finished project deliverables, set strategic directions, and so on. After the PPM management team is established,they must agree on a set of criteria for valuing projects in order to prioritize them. Decisions based on these criteria will likely be more acceptable to everyone in the organization if the criteria have been developed with the input or review of as many stakeholders as possible from within the various sub-organizations. So typically broad, organization-wide discussions of the criteria are held before they are finalized.
Why Should Project Managers Care about PPM?
Project managers who find themselves continually frustrated by lack of resources or by other organizations stealing their resources should be especially interested in PPM. These frustrations are symptoms of an unbalanced (or unacknowledged) project portfolio. In short, the frequent complaint of “not enough resources,” is simply another way of saying that there are too many projects! And if there are too many projects, then someone should be sorting them out, prioritizing them, and “killing” the projects that aren’t high priority.
Every project manager wants to have enough resources available to complete high-quality project deliverables, on-time and within budget. And every project manager wants to work on projects that are perceived to be valuable and, therefore, enjoy plenty of support throughout the organization. PPM can help project managers achieve both of these visions.
What Should Project Managers Do about PPM if None Exists in Their Organizations?
The average project manager is not in a position to implement PPM alone. Meaningful PPM cannot exist without the support and and active involvement of managers at the highest levels of the organization. But these senior managers are not likely to initiate PPM unless they are aware there is a documented need for it. So if you believe your organization could benefit by PPM, you need to first educate yourself, then build your case for PPM, and, finally, present this case to your senior managers. Here are some specific steps you might take:
1. Look for symptoms that PPM is needed and document them. Some of these symptoms include:
- Frequent difficulty finding enough people to put together a solid project team
- Excessive project delays due to “not enough resources”
- High turnover due to “burn out” of key project contributors because they are working on too many projects and spending too many overtime hours
- Frequent change of status of projects (i.e., moving from “active” to “on hold” to “top priority” and back)
- Completion of projects that, when all is said and done, don’t really meet a strategic need
- Intense competition, rather than cooperation, among departments and sub-organizations when staffing and funding projects
2. Learn more about PPM. You might:
- Talk to other professionals in your field and see how PPM is being applied in their companies.
- Search the internet and find out more about PPM.
- Examine these, and other, online articles:
- Datz, Todd, Portfolio Management: How to Do It Right [insights and methods used by senior managers using IT project portfolio management in major organizations], CIO Magazine (online), CIO Communications, Inc., May 1, 2003 [http://www.cio.com/archive/050103/portfolio.html]
- Waxer, Cindy, Portfolio Management: How Lowe’s Grows [describes how Lowe's goes beyond IT project portfolio management to enterprise portfolio management], CIO Magazine (online), CIO Communications, Inc., December 1, 2005 [http://www.cio.com/archive/120105/lowes.html]
- These UMT White Papers available at http://www.umt.com:
* The Seven Habits of Highly Effective Portfolio Management Implementations (2005 Edition): Proven Best Practices That Work
* The Efficient Frontier Technique for Analyzing Project Portfolio Management (November 2003)
- Check out these vendors who provide PPM support services, background information, PPM software, and more:
- Artemis International — www.aisc.com
- Business Engine — www.businessengine.com
- Barometrix — www.barometrix.com
- Mercury — www.mercury.com
- Pacific Edge — www.pacificedge.com
- PeopleSoft — www.peoplesoft.com
- Primavera — www.primavera.com
- ProSight — www.prosight.com
- IBM — www-306.ibm.com/software/awdtools/portfolio/
- Intersect Software – http://www.intersectsoft.com/
- UMT — www.umt.com
3. Document your resource requirements and share these with senior management. Specifically:
- Create “high resolution” project plans that accurately spell out, in vivid detail, the resources required to complete each task and activity
- Capture the actual hours spent by all project players in completing project tasks and activities
- Create summary tables showing planned and actual time spent by each person in your organization on every project to which he or she is assigned in order to demonstrate who’s overloaded
- Document all incidents of resources that are “stolen” across projects, excessive overtime, large-effort-but-ultimately-useless projects, and so on.
- By conducting project “post mortem” evaluations, gather information about how systematic PPM might have prevented problems and encouraged successes. (See Greer’s online tool Project “Post Mortem” Review Questions.)
4. Make your case for establishing PPM in your organization.
Effective PPM can help make a project manager’s life much easier and more professionally rewarding. More importantly, it can help an organization align its project workload to meet its strategic goals, while making the best use of limited resources. But PPM can’t be effective without solid, well-documented project plans, accurate estimates of resource requirements, and accurate information about actual resources consumed. Project managers who are equipped with such high resolution project artifacts are in a good position to start a grass roots movement to sell PPM and help senior managers decide how to set up the best PPM system for their organizations. What’s more, once the PPM is up and running, it is these same high resolution artifacts that provide the accuracy necessary for good decision-making by the PPM team.
For more information about practical, step-by-step methods for creating high resolution project plans and corresponding tracking techniques, check out The Project Manager’s Partner, 2nd edition or consider having Greer conduct an in-house PM Basics workshop for your organization.